Thursday, March 5, 2015

What To Do When The Elephant Tamers Ignore The Elephant

Throughout the 19th century, the debate over slavery was the “elephant in the room” because an answer was never directly stated by authority. Instead, the authority sided with their own individual beliefs and fought against the opposing side- ignoring their opportunities in government to use their power to compromise with leaders from the other side of the debate.


My group's timeline of the slavery revolt.
Made with TimeLine app.
Description of events included in my group's timeline. 

            The first event we learned about in class was the Compromise of 1850. This compromise can be summed up into five parts. The majority of the parts worked in favor of slavery. Texas gave up its land expanding to Santa Fe, receiving $10 million, and entered as a slave state. This was a win for proslavery because it gave the south more land to run slavery. New Mexico, Nevada, Arizona, and Utah territories can vote proslavery or antislavery when they’re populated enough to be considered states. This is a win for proslavery because these territories can easily be filled with proslavery settlers who will vote in favor of slavery. The worst was the fugitive slave law. This says all Americans should work to return slaves to their owners. Many northerners had been working to help slaves escape slavery and this law prevented them from continuing to do so. It was obviously passed by proslavery government without the consultation of antislavery government. They had the opportunity to collaborate and find a solution, but they do not. Instead, they pass a law without the approval of officials from the opposite side of the argument. Americans ended up breaking this law anyways, so I was ineffective even through the eyes of the proslavery officials who passed it.

Caning of Charles Sumner.
Take from class notes on edline. 
Another example of the government immaturely ignoring their ability to solve the problem rather than simply fight with their side occurred in 1856 and is referred to as the “Caning of Charles Sumner”. Sumner was a leading republican and one of the leading voices against slavery in congress. He gave a speech called The Crime Against Kansas which attacked Southerners for attempting to force slavery in the territories. Representative Preston Brooks, a proslavery member of the House of Representatives, who was attending Sumner’s speech, was enraged by the accusations made towards the South. In attempt to defend the South, Brooks beat Sumner with his cane. In response to this, southerners showed great support towards Brooks, even mailing him canes with the message “beat him again”. Instead of confronting the issue with Sumner verbally and finding a long term solution that would benefit both of their sides, Brooks reacted in a way that only fueled the debate even more. The government officials at this time weren’t working towards ending the debate. They were making their opinions well known and sharing the messages their sides were trying to get across, but they refused to comprehend the possibility of compromise. Because of this, the debate went on for centuries longer than it should have. 

Monday, February 23, 2015

If the Blind Man Does Not Know His Own Race, Will He, Too, Be Plagued By It?

Slavery population in 1790.

Slavery population in 1860.
In the early 19th century, Americans were surviving off of their seemingly unstoppable cotton production during the Industrial Revolution. The process of cotton production consisted of the initial picking of the cotton in the south by slaves and selling it to the northerners where it was then made into textiles and sold for a profit. The issue that we focused on in class arose at the very start of the process. Northerners, most of which didn’t come in contact with slaves because their main source of wealth came out of the factories rather than the fields, found the concept of slavery to be unethical and degrading. Nevertheless, they used the cotton that was picked by the slaves. As inventions were made to the textile production which led to cotton becoming more profitable, slaves were put in higher demand. In just 70 years, the slave population grew from 690,000 in 1790 to 3,204,000 in 1860. Despite the North’s disapproval regarding the use of slaves, abolishing it wasn’t a realistic option. So long as the demand for cotton was growing and the country’s economy was becoming more and more dependent on the demand for textiles and cotton, the slaves who picked the cotton remained an essential part of maintaining the country’s economy at the time.

The system of slavery in America was a system based solely on race. We’ve all heard the expression “don’t judge a book by its cover”. We know that if we judge people by what they look like on the outside, we’ll never get to know them for who they are on the inside. Not only were slaves judged by their appearance, they were targeted for it. Anyone of African descent could be taken into slavery. In class we watched a documentary on Abdul Rahman, a prince from Futa Jallon, who was taken into slavery after his army was defeated. Despite Rahman being an air to a throne, he was still sentenced to a life of inferiority to the whites. Whites saw all African people as below them because of their race, when in reality they shouldn’t have been considered differently than the whites were considering themselves. Slaves held an extremely close relationship with their slave owners that drastically limited their freedom. But what, other than race, separated the slave owner from the slave? Every person, no matter what race, skin tone, or ethnic background, shares the same values and yearns for the same respect to be given to them by other people. Everyone wants to be viewed as capable of everything their neighbor is, and everyone deserves the chance to prove this capability. When invited to speak as a newly freed slave at a USA conference for the 4th of July, Fredrick Douglas said, describing the slaves response to the whites’ celebration of their freedom, “To him, your celebration is a sham… your shout of liberty and equality, hollow mockery.” He saw these white men living with a freedom they did nothing to earn, meanwhile they suppress their slaves, a people who have done nothing but fight for their freedom to no avail. To suppress someone for their race and appearance means they were never given a choice. They were born into that race. They were born with that skin tone. Slavery told an entire race of people that they’re nothing to be celebrated; merely a machine that can get jobs done. No human deserves to be treated that way. 

Maps: http://mappinghistory.uoregon.edu/english/US/US18-00.html 
Quote: Frederick Douglass, “The Meaning of July Fourth for the Negro,” a speech delivered in Rochester, New York, July 5, 1852.

Sunday, February 1, 2015

Estrogen and Testosterone Don't Decide Your Fate

Sphere of Women.
This illustration represents the many responsibilities
of women such as caring for pets, children, education,
all of which goes unacknowledged behind the curtain. 
In the 19th century, women were treated as belongings more often than people. They were expected to keep a tidy household, which includes responsibilities such as repairing broken things and keeping up their children’s tidy appearance. They were also in charge of educating the children, taking care of household pets, and were to expect no signs of gratitude or any acknowledgement whatsoever in return. They were not allowed to vote or own property. Women who spoke in public were deemed improper. When women saw that slaves, who had previously played the role of society’s suppressed, were fighting to get the rights and respect they deserved, they realized it was time for them to do the same. Women’s Reformers held a convention at Seneca Falls and wrote a document called The Declaration of Rights and Sentiments that specifically stated their resolutions to obtain the rights that had been previously withheld from them. 

Needless to say, the idea of women being independent and treated as such evoked mixed reviews in the public. Some were supportive. A newspaper called The North Star, an abolitionists’ paper, wrote, “Standing as we do upon the watch-tower of human freedom, we cannot be deterred from an expression of our approbation of any movement, however humble, to improve and elevate the character and condition of any members of the human family.” This is saying if people are keeping others from enjoying the rights they deserve, then they themselves shouldn’t be privileged with said rights. No person should view themselves as more important than another person. Women have the right to rise above society’s oppression and no part of society should try to stop them. Other papers weren’t nearly as supportive. A newspaper called Oneida Whig made the point, “If our ladies will insist on voting and legislature, where, gentlemen, will be our dinners and our elbows?” This is saying that if women are recognized in society and given the chance to participate in politics, they won’t have enough time to take care of the household. And because that has been their only responsibility up until this point, why should they be allowed to slack off just so they can go run alongside the men of society? Some, like The North Star, were supportive in the women’s determination to gain rights, and others, like Oneida Whig, were stupid.

In the 21st century, we recognize that The North Star has a more appropriate response to the women’s demands than the second, but have we completely resolved the issues these women were looking to take care of? Sure, we can vote now. My prayers are with the man who tells his wife it’s improper to open her mouth in public. But women and men still have certain connotations that correspond with society’s ideal image of their existence. What do you think of when you hear the word ‘manly’? It reminds me of strength, independence, and someone who refuses to give someone else the satisfaction of being in control. Is it wrong for a woman to work towards these characteristics too? What do you think of when you hear the word ‘feminine’? It reminds me of sensitivity, surrounding yourself with what makes you feel good, and opening yourself up to those around you. Is it wrong for a man to describe himself with these characteristics? Before we can level the playing field for men and women, we need to accept that the gender of someone doesn't limit them in terms of what kind of a person they are and what they’re capable of.


For another look at the differing perceptions of men vs women in society, check out this Pantene commercial from 2013:

Sunday, January 11, 2015

Nobody Knows What Goes On Behind Locked Doors


 "...I turned my attention to the prunes and found that very few of them would be sufficient. A patient near asked me to give them to her. I did so. My bowl of tea was all that was left. I tasted, and one taste was enough. It had no sugar, and it tasted as if it had been made in copper. It was as weak as water. This was also transferred to a hungrier patient, in spite of the protest of Miss Neville. 'You must force the food down,' she said, 'else you will be sick, and who knows but what, with these surroundings, you may go crazy. To have a good brain the stomach must be cared for.' 'It is impossible for me to eat that stuff,' I replied, and, despite all her urging, I ate nothing that night."

Nellie Bly, Ten Days in a Mad-House (New York City: Ian L. Munro, 1887) 


            This excerpt comes from one of Nellie Bly’s recounts of her time in the asylum. Nellie was given the assignment to observe the conditions in a major New York mental institution and to publish her observations through an American press outlet for the public. Nellie was a journalist who devoted herself to working on projects that only pertained to subjects she was passionate about. She typically wrote only in regards to the women’s rights movements, but when this aspect of society that was also responsible for oppressing people and giving them unfair treatment was brought to her attention, she eagerly took on the assignment. I consider this source to be very trustworthy because it was written by Nellie herself during her time in the asylum. I drew this specific excerpt from a page on pbs pbs.org. Nellie’s findings were published in 1887, 19 years after Elizabeth Parsons’ The Prisoners' Hidden Life and 44 years after Dorothea Dix’s Memorial to the Legislature of Massachusetts . Because she was published after these two widely known works, the public knew that the conditions in the mental institutions were not at the level they should be. But Nellie took a different view on things. Unlike Parson and Dix, who entered the asylums as journalists, Nellie checked herself in as a mental patient. Under the name “Nellie Brown”, Bly convinced an array of people that she had lost her mind, which led to her confinement on Blackwell’s Island for ten days. Because Nellie was a patient and received the treatment that all other patients were given, she could fully immerse herself in what she was informing the public of and could provide her readers with complete and accurate information. Nellie was writing to show that the institutions these ill people were put in were far from being beneficial for their health. She says that the food was so unappealing that she chose to continue on hungry than to force it down. An onlooker told her, “to have a good brain the stomach must be cared for”. The food given to these patients was far from nutritious, and wouldn’t fulfill the caring that needs to be done to the stomach in order to have a “good brain”, even if Nellie had been able to make herself consume it. Nellie’s entries effectively show that these asylums offered no help to the ailing and if there is to be any improvement made to their health, better conditions need to be implemented. 

Wednesday, December 10, 2014

The System That Almost Spoiled America

This week my class took on the challenge of accurately assessing Andrew Jackson’s reputation as “the people’s president” and attempting to decide whether it was a deserved title or not. This is an important point to think about because, as a democracy, we like our leaders to be working for the people each ad every day. Reflecting on past leaders and their efforts to be "the people's president" gives us insight into what our current leaders are thinking and whether their actions are really as democratic as we would like them to be. My class split into six groups and each took on a certain aspect of Jackson’s presidency. The six groups chose between researching the bank war, the Indian removal act, or the spoils system. My group chose last and, because of this, got stuck with the choice the other groups had neglected, which happened to be the spoils system.

The bank war groups showed us that, even though it didn't turn out well for America, Andrew Jackson had vetoed the bank with American's best interests in mind. The bank favored the higher classes and, by vetoing it, he was supporting the lower and middle classes, which were the majority of the population. Even if it didn't turn out well, his intentions could be described as being for the people. The Indian removal group showed us that Andrew Jackson should not be considered the people's president. He was trying to look out for the American people, but he wasn't looking out for all people, seeing as the Indians faced incredible suffrage due to this act. So we had one group in favor of his reputation and one group against it; it was up to the spoils groups to decide how Jackson should be remembered. Despite the fact we received the topic involuntarily, I found the spoils system to be a rather intriguing topic. We read through our online documents and created a common craft video summarizing what the system was. We came to the conclusion that Jackson wasn’t "the people’s president" because he gave positions based on loyalty rather than intelligence and merit. It would benefit the people more if they were run by electives who knew what they were doing, rather than just a group of people untied under the requests and orders of a single man. Not only that, but the spoils system ended up having a negative effect on America and, therefore, proves that Jackson should not be remembered as a good president, let alone one for the people.

Tuesday, December 2, 2014

Democracy is Spelled USA

My class has spent these past two days learning about the rise of democracy in America during the 19th century. We read through and analyzed primary source documents as well as charts and background essays to understand just how our government took shape. We then used these documents to create a presentation of the information we gathered to decide how much of a democracy this country was in the 19th century. 






Tuesday, November 25, 2014

The Color of Your Skin Doesn't Change the Color of Your Heart

We spent this week discussing the importance of human value. Do not fret, for it was not a week’s worth of, “Your smile is beautiful but your heart is beautifuller”. More appropriately, we focused on the acknowledgement of human values regardless of race and found evidence of this social imperative in the Latin American Revolutions. To start off our lesson, we took notes on the social rank of each racial group in the Latin American social structure as well as the percent that group made up of the population. The population was made up of 11% Peninsulares, 23% Creoles, 7% Mestizos, 8% Mulattoes and Free Blacks, 50% Indian peoples, and 11% slaves. If you were a Peninsulare, you were a European from the Iberian Peninsula (Spain or Portugal). If you were a Creole, you descended from Europeans but you were born in the New World. If you were a Mestizo, you descended from one white parent and one parent with Indian heritage. If you were a Mulatto, you were a free person of color (having at least one parent of African descent). Indians were the people living in Latin America before the Spanish colonized there. Slaves were of African descent, some even born in Africa. And, as history has often showed, the people with power made up the smallest percentages of the population: the Peninsulares.

My group's timeline of the Mexican Revolution
When comparing the Brazil, the Gran Colombia, and the Mexico revolutions we discovered some similarities between the three outbreaks. All three revolts were around the early 1800s and they were all against European countries who colonized and controlled them. All of the people not of European decent were fighting against the Peninsulares (lower class against the upper class). The revolutions were also somewhat different in that Gran Columbia and Mexico took place in Spain and were both very violent revolts, unlike Brazil, which took place in Portugal, and provoked very little fighting. Both Brazil and Gran Columbia had a government made up of only Peninsulares and the mixed lower classes wanted to overthrow them. Mexico was run by Peninsulares as well as Creoles. Countries were choosing their leaders based on race (white people in power, people of mixed race were in lower classes) rather than choosing them in a way that considers the real aspects of a good leader. Our class has just written a DBQ about Toussaint Louverture, the leader of a widely known slave rebellion. He was African American and possessed amazing leadership qualities. If his race were to prevent him from spreading his influence on those that were affected by it in a positive way, that would change history for the worse. When you’re a kid, you must’ve been told, “It’s what’s on the inside that counts”. If someone’s outward appearance blinds us from the capable qualities they possess, then revolts will inevitably and rightfully occur.

I think it’s very rare that, in our society today, we’ll make it through a whole month without hearing a story about racial discrimination. It’s hard for people to not consider someone’s race when figuring out their first impression of them. I’m not saying it’s right for someone to judge another person based off their race, but it’s hard for most people to ignore it. Then, in addition to that, there’s the dispute if it’s right for us to ignore it. Last year, in history, we took a survey about the future of America and one question asked if America should be colorblind or a melting pot; one ignoring all race and one embracing the different cultures and heritages. Either one is in support of equal rights. No one’s race should determine what they’re capable of; let alone what they’re incapable of.