Monday, June 15, 2015

Sharing Is Caring: The American Government Was Neither

After the Civil War, America found itself with a new goal: settling. And when gold was discovered in the Midwest, the incentive for settling became a lot shinier (literally). As we all know, when Christopher Columbus sailed the ocean blue, that chunk of land he mistakenly found himself upon was not uninhabited. And now, along with the weight of factoring newly freed slaves into society, America also had to deal with these horrible tribes they found taking up their new living space. Let’s just say Americans did not believe in the first come, first gets-to-stay-in-their-homes policy.

ABC-CLIO Federal Native American Policies Visual.
In the events detailed above, it's clear the settlers and American government
never respected the Native Americans and the land they had owned long
before the settlers came along.
Native Americans: Intention vs. Actions
The government has never been a fan of sharing, and that was true back when they were first settling the country. Many leaders looked at natives as a “barrier to civilization”. In an ABC-Clio video, my class and I learned about Henry Pratt, an American white man who was strongly opposed to the Native American lifestyle. He established schools for the children of tribes in an effort to “kill the Indian”. Pratt believed in order to save the man, the Indian inside of him must be killed. Another day in class we read the Dawes Act of 1887, a document clearly establishing white superiority, allowing them to control the lives of the Native Americans and where those lives could take place. The document ends by saying, “with consent of a majority of the adult male members of said tribe”. This means whites were not technically given the right to abuse Native Americans or force them out of their established living spaces without their consent. Did this stop us? Does it ever?? We continued removing and forcing these tribes out of their homes. The Dawes Act may have provided a safety around the Natives, protecting their tribes by requiring their consent, but this was not enforced and, from the looks of what I’ve seen, the government didn’t make any effort to protect the rights they said they would. In a more specific turn of events, the Second Treaty of Laramie in 1868, officially granted the Dakota territory west of the Missouri River to the tribes. Although this land was declared property of the tribes, this stopped no one, as settlers continued their way onto the Native Americans’ territories.

Buffalo Soldiers: Intention vs. Actions
An image from the PBS video we watched in class.
Buffalo soldiers were thrown onto the toughest terrain. Given only horses to
travel with, soldiers often ended up walking because riding horseback on such
terrain was dangerous. 
Buffalo soldiers were African American soldiers previously on the side of the Union in the Civil War who had decided to continue fighting for the American military. We learned in the ABC-Clio video that from the very start, these soldiers were not considered to be on the same tier as other soldiers. They were stationed in the roughest terrain; locations other soldiers refused to work in. The buffalo is an animal that can provide food as well as clothing to its hunter—this is more than can be said of the American government’s actions toward the Buffalo soldiers. Buffalo soldiers were not only sent through the rough terrain, but they were expected to civilize it, setting up railroads, telegraph lines, and to map the unknown territories. These soldiers shouldn’t have been sent blindly into questionable locations to begin with, let alone be forced to work in them for weeks at a time. In a PBS Video we watched in class, it was clear that no matter where these soldiers were stationed, they were never treated with the respect they deserved. When they were sent into already civilized locations, it wasn’t much better. There were significant prejudices against blacks even after slaves had been freed. They didn’t have the authority they needed to watch over established cities and towns because the people inhabiting these locations couldn’t see a black man as someone of authority. Whether in uncharted territories or established cities, Buffalo soldiers weren’t treated the way they deserved.

A Purposefully Impossible Intent

Looking at the documents from this time regarding Natives and Buffalo Soldiers, the government never stated that these peoples should be treated differently. They demanded that a tribe’s consent must be given before anything is done and that Buffalo soldiers would protect the country much like any other soldiers. Unfortunately, these ideas were not enforced. I believe that the government knew these intentions wouldn’t bode well for the tribes and soldiers. Tribes were removed with ease because the government showed no enforcement of the protection they gave to the tribes. And in terms of the Buffalo Soldiers, the government never established the authority they needed to succeed. The government may have said these groups should receive equal treatment, but they never enforced it, and because of that these groups were always at a disadvantage. 

Sunday, June 7, 2015

Almost A Robin Hood: Stealing From The Middle To Give To The Poor

After the civil war, America needed to repair not only their homes, but also their economy. This took the power of innovators, now referred to as Captains of Industry. Some of these groundbreaking men consisted of Andrew Carnegie, J.P Morgan, John D. Rockefeller, and many others. Although these men worked effortlessly to bring an era of innovation alive, it’s debatable whether or not they were had a positive effect on America. Positive—because they brought in funds and work ethics which helped to inspired Americans towards a brighter future. Negative—because they showed little appreciation to their employees who helped to bring their ideas alive. Now the question is which of these effected Americans more?

Wow! These guys are great!
In class we watched an ABC Clio video which gave us an overview of the unit. Splitting into groups to take notes on a specific aspect of the video (main ideas, key people, important events, or essential terms) we got a general understanding of the success of these Captains of Industry. After the video we read through bios of Carnegie and Rockelfeller which went into the specifics of their industry. By the end of their careers, both men had made mass donations to charitable organizations bettering America after the war. They put the money they had worked hard to earn towards helping the poor. John D. Rockefeller in an interview with William Hoster, quoted in God's Gold (1932) by John T. Flynn, said, “I believe it is my duty to make money and still more money and to use the money I make for the good of my fellow man.” Throughout one of the toughest times in American history, The Great Depression, these men strived to make a life for themselves and provide for others. With their understanding of materials people couldn’t live without, Rockefeller working with oil industries and Carnegie producing steel, they set up businesses that would strive even in the toughest conditions. But were they using their power for good?

Maybe not so much…
"Forty-Millionaire Carnegie in his Great Double Role," The
 Saturday Globe, 9 July 1892; from David P. Demares.

To the right Carnegie gives money to charitable organizations,
to the left he lowers the wages of his employees. 
Watching the video recap of Carnegie and Rockefeller’s successes may have left us in awe of their drive and effective business tactics, but when we took a closer look at primary soures from this time period, we realized they may not have been the superheroes America needed. In a comic strip pictured to the left, it’s clear Carnegie was not as generous to his workers as he was to charities and other organizations. Carnegie may have been a saint towards those who were at a disadvantage compared to the rest of society, but during The Great Depression, the “rest of society” wasn’t at much of an advantage to begin with. Carnegie helped the lowest classes by donating his mass of wealth, but his employees’ unfair wages didn’t help the middle class with their own problems. Seeing as the middle class makes up a majority of society and that the economy was hurting during this time, a focus should’ve been put on the middle class. If they had received the wages and support Carnegie and Rockefeller were giving to the lowest classes, they would’ve been perpetuated into bettering their financial situations and stabilizing the economy for all classes. These captain of industry were, without a doubt, helping some parts of society, but it wasn’t the part of society that needed the most help at this time.

They were the best the Great Depression had to offer

Although these guys may not have given their workers a ticket to a bright and glorious future, they gave their workers something; which was more than most businesses were doing during this time. Most corporations were either firing the majority of their staff or shutting down the business altogether. Carnegie and Rockefeller at least gave their workers a steady income, even if that income wasn’t the best it could be. Given the circumstances of America’s economy during this time, the captains of industry provided their employees with more than most businesses: a stable job, and for that I believe they had a positive impact on America. 

Wednesday, April 29, 2015

The Bottom Got A Boost From The Top

An argument stands in society today regarding the slaves' victory during the civil war: did their freedom come from above or below? In other words, did the slaves earn their own freedom (from below) or was it given to them from a higher power (above)? This week we looked at primary documents that supported different sides of this argument and decided on our own where we believed the freedom was born. 


Freedom From The Top?
At this time Lincoln was the president, so if freedom were to come from above, it would come from him. We read a collection of his speeches which grew to specify his desire to free the slaves. At the beginning of the war, he declared his goal as bringing the union together. In Lincoln's reply to an Open Letter from Horace Greely in 1862, he said, "My paramount object in thus struggle is to save the Union and is not either to save or to destroy slavery." Later in the war Lincoln comes out to clearly state his goal clearly to abolish slavery entirely. In his second inaugural address on March 4th, 1865, Lincoln said, "If we shall suppose that American slavery is one of those offenses which, in the providence of God., must needs come... he now wills to remove." This is saying that he believes slavery needed to happen, and no that it has happened it is his duty to remove it. He's going to work on removing slavery for the slaves- they can just chill out and wait for him to come to their rescue.

Engraving, “Slaves from the plantation of
Confederate President Jefferson Davis arrive at
Chickasaw Bayou, Mississippi,” 1863
.

Slaves marching through the glances of military officials.
Or Freedom From The Bottom? 
Aside from Lincoln's subtle desire to end slavery, slaves were taking it upon themselves to earn their freedom. In order to get their point across, slaves forced themselves into present issues, such as marching into territory where military leaders were residing (shown in picture), which brought an urgency to the slave's noncooperation which had to be brought up with he president. They worked their message through the ranks and gained the president's attention. 



The Verdict Is In...
An exaggerated portrayal of a slave worshiping
Lincoln and all he has done as an abolitionist.
I believe slavery came from the top. In addition to Lincoln's efforts shown in the documents we read (described earlier in this post), the efforts of the slaves earning their freedom from below can be credited to the president as well. Although slaves were independent and gained the recognition of the president on their own, it was because of the personal beliefs of their president that their actions were so well received. Since Lincoln was opposed to slavery on his own terms, he supported he slaves actions to free themselves. If he had been personally opposed to abolitionists, he would have used his power to put an end to the slaves' revolts and prevented their message to get as far as it did. Although Lincoln was not looking for praise in response to his actions in assisting the slaves (shown in picture), he should be credited as the major reason slavery was abolished-- therefore, slavery came from the top. 

 

Friday, April 10, 2015

The Day C Block Was Set Free

What do you call a class of high schoolers roaming from floor to floor in a race for who can copy and paste the fastest? A #gallagherhistory scavenger hunt.

The week commenced with each student, or in my case a pair of students, picking a specific battle of the civil war to research. We chose from a list of descriptions and used the information given to find the battle. I picked the Battle of Fort Sumter. My partner and I set up a Google doc in which we typed up the following:
- Name of battle
- Place of battle
- Date
- Victor
- Theater (East, West, or Naval)
- Main reason(s) for results

Battle of Fort Sumter.
This is the picture featured for our battle.
The final bullet took some analyzing. We had to research the outcome of the battle and consider the state of both sides and the effect these had on the results. In the end, we complied all of this information in our Google doc and added a picture along with citations. 

We then created a new document which we would post up somewhere in the school. We inserted a QR code (made using the QR Reader app) that would link to our Google doc. But, because the QR readers and BYOD are fussy, we also added a shortened URL to our doc. We used bit.ly to customize the link and make it easier for our classmates to type in. Our finished document looked something like this. 

Once the documents were posted around school it was time to roam. We went from stop to stop taking down the information about each battle in our Evernote. Back into the classroom and it's time to analyze our findings. We set up a Padlet with three categories: East, West, and Naval. Each student individually chose a category and stated which side (confederate or union) he thought dominated in that theater. Within these results we found that the Union was the clear victor in the West and Naval theaters, but the East theater lead to a little controversy. We discussed the change that occurred in this theater. At the beginning of the Civil War, due to the Union's lack of military leadership, the Confederate side dominated. Once the Union established stronger leadership, they became the dominating theater. And once this occurred, the Union was in the lead of all three theaters-- a shoe-in for the victors of the war.  

Wednesday, March 18, 2015

We Should've Seen It Coming: The American Civil War



This week in class we looked at the divisions between proslavery and antislavery activists caused by the events in the Election of 1860 and how these divisions led to the American Civil War. We started the week by watching the CrashCourse video on the Civil War. Then, throughout the week, we worked on creating documentaries using Educreations, outlining the events leading up to the Civil War. We used a multimedia website as an outline for the information we would use and found three outside images to feature in our video. My group had a little trouble recording the video: we forgot to add a voice recording over the title slide and added it after the fact, pushing the title slide back to the point in the project in which we recorded it. Educreations is not my favorite recording tool, but it was useful in stringing together our compiled data to highlight the main ideas of our topic. 

Thursday, March 12, 2015

North Rules South Drools



This past week my class and I created infographics to illustrate the difference between the North and South and how their differences affected each region’s strategy and success in the civil war. I chose to make my infographic using infogr.am. In terms of advantages, the South was mainly carrying themselves on their profit from agriculture, which is why I started my infographic with information about their crops. My infographic then carried on to provide information on the North’s strong suits, of which there seemed to be many. I got the majority of these characteristics from a document describing the advantages of the North and South and another document which provided exact statistics for the information I displayed in my infographic. I concluded my infographic with a display of the differing populations. Because the South didn’t have enough people to fight in the war and keep their economy up, they decided they would bring outside forces on their side to build up their numbers. The South denied their exports to Great Britain and France in hopes Europe would support them in order to gain their cotton back. Europe instead turned to Egypt and India for their cotton, leaving the Deep South in deep trouble. On the other hand, although the South had only a fraction of the North’s population, most of the country’s military colleges and trained officers were in the South. And, because the Northerners were seeking to abolish an already existent system in the South, requiring them to raid and overtake all Southerners, the North’s route of battle seemed much harder to take than the South’s. Southerners planned on a war of attrition, which meant they would turn back union forces until they lost the will to fight. This backfired- the Northern spirits only grew stronger. They knew what they wanted to fight for and would not rest until it was achieved. Rather than simply looking at the statistics of the war, this project gave us the opportunity to analyze data given to us and find it’s relevancy to the outcome of the war. I have a strong understanding of the impact these statistics had on the American Civil War. 


Thursday, March 5, 2015

What To Do When The Elephant Tamers Ignore The Elephant

Throughout the 19th century, the debate over slavery was the “elephant in the room” because an answer was never directly stated by authority. Instead, the authority sided with their own individual beliefs and fought against the opposing side- ignoring their opportunities in government to use their power to compromise with leaders from the other side of the debate.


My group's timeline of the slavery revolt.
Made with TimeLine app.
Description of events included in my group's timeline. 

            The first event we learned about in class was the Compromise of 1850. This compromise can be summed up into five parts. The majority of the parts worked in favor of slavery. Texas gave up its land expanding to Santa Fe, receiving $10 million, and entered as a slave state. This was a win for proslavery because it gave the south more land to run slavery. New Mexico, Nevada, Arizona, and Utah territories can vote proslavery or antislavery when they’re populated enough to be considered states. This is a win for proslavery because these territories can easily be filled with proslavery settlers who will vote in favor of slavery. The worst was the fugitive slave law. This says all Americans should work to return slaves to their owners. Many northerners had been working to help slaves escape slavery and this law prevented them from continuing to do so. It was obviously passed by proslavery government without the consultation of antislavery government. They had the opportunity to collaborate and find a solution, but they do not. Instead, they pass a law without the approval of officials from the opposite side of the argument. Americans ended up breaking this law anyways, so I was ineffective even through the eyes of the proslavery officials who passed it.

Caning of Charles Sumner.
Take from class notes on edline. 
Another example of the government immaturely ignoring their ability to solve the problem rather than simply fight with their side occurred in 1856 and is referred to as the “Caning of Charles Sumner”. Sumner was a leading republican and one of the leading voices against slavery in congress. He gave a speech called The Crime Against Kansas which attacked Southerners for attempting to force slavery in the territories. Representative Preston Brooks, a proslavery member of the House of Representatives, who was attending Sumner’s speech, was enraged by the accusations made towards the South. In attempt to defend the South, Brooks beat Sumner with his cane. In response to this, southerners showed great support towards Brooks, even mailing him canes with the message “beat him again”. Instead of confronting the issue with Sumner verbally and finding a long term solution that would benefit both of their sides, Brooks reacted in a way that only fueled the debate even more. The government officials at this time weren’t working towards ending the debate. They were making their opinions well known and sharing the messages their sides were trying to get across, but they refused to comprehend the possibility of compromise. Because of this, the debate went on for centuries longer than it should have. 

Monday, February 23, 2015

If the Blind Man Does Not Know His Own Race, Will He, Too, Be Plagued By It?

Slavery population in 1790.

Slavery population in 1860.
In the early 19th century, Americans were surviving off of their seemingly unstoppable cotton production during the Industrial Revolution. The process of cotton production consisted of the initial picking of the cotton in the south by slaves and selling it to the northerners where it was then made into textiles and sold for a profit. The issue that we focused on in class arose at the very start of the process. Northerners, most of which didn’t come in contact with slaves because their main source of wealth came out of the factories rather than the fields, found the concept of slavery to be unethical and degrading. Nevertheless, they used the cotton that was picked by the slaves. As inventions were made to the textile production which led to cotton becoming more profitable, slaves were put in higher demand. In just 70 years, the slave population grew from 690,000 in 1790 to 3,204,000 in 1860. Despite the North’s disapproval regarding the use of slaves, abolishing it wasn’t a realistic option. So long as the demand for cotton was growing and the country’s economy was becoming more and more dependent on the demand for textiles and cotton, the slaves who picked the cotton remained an essential part of maintaining the country’s economy at the time.

The system of slavery in America was a system based solely on race. We’ve all heard the expression “don’t judge a book by its cover”. We know that if we judge people by what they look like on the outside, we’ll never get to know them for who they are on the inside. Not only were slaves judged by their appearance, they were targeted for it. Anyone of African descent could be taken into slavery. In class we watched a documentary on Abdul Rahman, a prince from Futa Jallon, who was taken into slavery after his army was defeated. Despite Rahman being an air to a throne, he was still sentenced to a life of inferiority to the whites. Whites saw all African people as below them because of their race, when in reality they shouldn’t have been considered differently than the whites were considering themselves. Slaves held an extremely close relationship with their slave owners that drastically limited their freedom. But what, other than race, separated the slave owner from the slave? Every person, no matter what race, skin tone, or ethnic background, shares the same values and yearns for the same respect to be given to them by other people. Everyone wants to be viewed as capable of everything their neighbor is, and everyone deserves the chance to prove this capability. When invited to speak as a newly freed slave at a USA conference for the 4th of July, Fredrick Douglas said, describing the slaves response to the whites’ celebration of their freedom, “To him, your celebration is a sham… your shout of liberty and equality, hollow mockery.” He saw these white men living with a freedom they did nothing to earn, meanwhile they suppress their slaves, a people who have done nothing but fight for their freedom to no avail. To suppress someone for their race and appearance means they were never given a choice. They were born into that race. They were born with that skin tone. Slavery told an entire race of people that they’re nothing to be celebrated; merely a machine that can get jobs done. No human deserves to be treated that way. 

Maps: http://mappinghistory.uoregon.edu/english/US/US18-00.html 
Quote: Frederick Douglass, “The Meaning of July Fourth for the Negro,” a speech delivered in Rochester, New York, July 5, 1852.

Sunday, February 1, 2015

Estrogen and Testosterone Don't Decide Your Fate

Sphere of Women.
This illustration represents the many responsibilities
of women such as caring for pets, children, education,
all of which goes unacknowledged behind the curtain. 
In the 19th century, women were treated as belongings more often than people. They were expected to keep a tidy household, which includes responsibilities such as repairing broken things and keeping up their children’s tidy appearance. They were also in charge of educating the children, taking care of household pets, and were to expect no signs of gratitude or any acknowledgement whatsoever in return. They were not allowed to vote or own property. Women who spoke in public were deemed improper. When women saw that slaves, who had previously played the role of society’s suppressed, were fighting to get the rights and respect they deserved, they realized it was time for them to do the same. Women’s Reformers held a convention at Seneca Falls and wrote a document called The Declaration of Rights and Sentiments that specifically stated their resolutions to obtain the rights that had been previously withheld from them. 

Needless to say, the idea of women being independent and treated as such evoked mixed reviews in the public. Some were supportive. A newspaper called The North Star, an abolitionists’ paper, wrote, “Standing as we do upon the watch-tower of human freedom, we cannot be deterred from an expression of our approbation of any movement, however humble, to improve and elevate the character and condition of any members of the human family.” This is saying if people are keeping others from enjoying the rights they deserve, then they themselves shouldn’t be privileged with said rights. No person should view themselves as more important than another person. Women have the right to rise above society’s oppression and no part of society should try to stop them. Other papers weren’t nearly as supportive. A newspaper called Oneida Whig made the point, “If our ladies will insist on voting and legislature, where, gentlemen, will be our dinners and our elbows?” This is saying that if women are recognized in society and given the chance to participate in politics, they won’t have enough time to take care of the household. And because that has been their only responsibility up until this point, why should they be allowed to slack off just so they can go run alongside the men of society? Some, like The North Star, were supportive in the women’s determination to gain rights, and others, like Oneida Whig, were stupid.

In the 21st century, we recognize that The North Star has a more appropriate response to the women’s demands than the second, but have we completely resolved the issues these women were looking to take care of? Sure, we can vote now. My prayers are with the man who tells his wife it’s improper to open her mouth in public. But women and men still have certain connotations that correspond with society’s ideal image of their existence. What do you think of when you hear the word ‘manly’? It reminds me of strength, independence, and someone who refuses to give someone else the satisfaction of being in control. Is it wrong for a woman to work towards these characteristics too? What do you think of when you hear the word ‘feminine’? It reminds me of sensitivity, surrounding yourself with what makes you feel good, and opening yourself up to those around you. Is it wrong for a man to describe himself with these characteristics? Before we can level the playing field for men and women, we need to accept that the gender of someone doesn't limit them in terms of what kind of a person they are and what they’re capable of.


For another look at the differing perceptions of men vs women in society, check out this Pantene commercial from 2013:

Sunday, January 11, 2015

Nobody Knows What Goes On Behind Locked Doors


 "...I turned my attention to the prunes and found that very few of them would be sufficient. A patient near asked me to give them to her. I did so. My bowl of tea was all that was left. I tasted, and one taste was enough. It had no sugar, and it tasted as if it had been made in copper. It was as weak as water. This was also transferred to a hungrier patient, in spite of the protest of Miss Neville. 'You must force the food down,' she said, 'else you will be sick, and who knows but what, with these surroundings, you may go crazy. To have a good brain the stomach must be cared for.' 'It is impossible for me to eat that stuff,' I replied, and, despite all her urging, I ate nothing that night."

Nellie Bly, Ten Days in a Mad-House (New York City: Ian L. Munro, 1887) 


            This excerpt comes from one of Nellie Bly’s recounts of her time in the asylum. Nellie was given the assignment to observe the conditions in a major New York mental institution and to publish her observations through an American press outlet for the public. Nellie was a journalist who devoted herself to working on projects that only pertained to subjects she was passionate about. She typically wrote only in regards to the women’s rights movements, but when this aspect of society that was also responsible for oppressing people and giving them unfair treatment was brought to her attention, she eagerly took on the assignment. I consider this source to be very trustworthy because it was written by Nellie herself during her time in the asylum. I drew this specific excerpt from a page on pbs pbs.org. Nellie’s findings were published in 1887, 19 years after Elizabeth Parsons’ The Prisoners' Hidden Life and 44 years after Dorothea Dix’s Memorial to the Legislature of Massachusetts . Because she was published after these two widely known works, the public knew that the conditions in the mental institutions were not at the level they should be. But Nellie took a different view on things. Unlike Parson and Dix, who entered the asylums as journalists, Nellie checked herself in as a mental patient. Under the name “Nellie Brown”, Bly convinced an array of people that she had lost her mind, which led to her confinement on Blackwell’s Island for ten days. Because Nellie was a patient and received the treatment that all other patients were given, she could fully immerse herself in what she was informing the public of and could provide her readers with complete and accurate information. Nellie was writing to show that the institutions these ill people were put in were far from being beneficial for their health. She says that the food was so unappealing that she chose to continue on hungry than to force it down. An onlooker told her, “to have a good brain the stomach must be cared for”. The food given to these patients was far from nutritious, and wouldn’t fulfill the caring that needs to be done to the stomach in order to have a “good brain”, even if Nellie had been able to make herself consume it. Nellie’s entries effectively show that these asylums offered no help to the ailing and if there is to be any improvement made to their health, better conditions need to be implemented. 

Wednesday, December 10, 2014

The System That Almost Spoiled America

This week my class took on the challenge of accurately assessing Andrew Jackson’s reputation as “the people’s president” and attempting to decide whether it was a deserved title or not. This is an important point to think about because, as a democracy, we like our leaders to be working for the people each ad every day. Reflecting on past leaders and their efforts to be "the people's president" gives us insight into what our current leaders are thinking and whether their actions are really as democratic as we would like them to be. My class split into six groups and each took on a certain aspect of Jackson’s presidency. The six groups chose between researching the bank war, the Indian removal act, or the spoils system. My group chose last and, because of this, got stuck with the choice the other groups had neglected, which happened to be the spoils system.

The bank war groups showed us that, even though it didn't turn out well for America, Andrew Jackson had vetoed the bank with American's best interests in mind. The bank favored the higher classes and, by vetoing it, he was supporting the lower and middle classes, which were the majority of the population. Even if it didn't turn out well, his intentions could be described as being for the people. The Indian removal group showed us that Andrew Jackson should not be considered the people's president. He was trying to look out for the American people, but he wasn't looking out for all people, seeing as the Indians faced incredible suffrage due to this act. So we had one group in favor of his reputation and one group against it; it was up to the spoils groups to decide how Jackson should be remembered. Despite the fact we received the topic involuntarily, I found the spoils system to be a rather intriguing topic. We read through our online documents and created a common craft video summarizing what the system was. We came to the conclusion that Jackson wasn’t "the people’s president" because he gave positions based on loyalty rather than intelligence and merit. It would benefit the people more if they were run by electives who knew what they were doing, rather than just a group of people untied under the requests and orders of a single man. Not only that, but the spoils system ended up having a negative effect on America and, therefore, proves that Jackson should not be remembered as a good president, let alone one for the people.

Tuesday, December 2, 2014

Democracy is Spelled USA

My class has spent these past two days learning about the rise of democracy in America during the 19th century. We read through and analyzed primary source documents as well as charts and background essays to understand just how our government took shape. We then used these documents to create a presentation of the information we gathered to decide how much of a democracy this country was in the 19th century. 






Tuesday, November 25, 2014

The Color of Your Skin Doesn't Change the Color of Your Heart

We spent this week discussing the importance of human value. Do not fret, for it was not a week’s worth of, “Your smile is beautiful but your heart is beautifuller”. More appropriately, we focused on the acknowledgement of human values regardless of race and found evidence of this social imperative in the Latin American Revolutions. To start off our lesson, we took notes on the social rank of each racial group in the Latin American social structure as well as the percent that group made up of the population. The population was made up of 11% Peninsulares, 23% Creoles, 7% Mestizos, 8% Mulattoes and Free Blacks, 50% Indian peoples, and 11% slaves. If you were a Peninsulare, you were a European from the Iberian Peninsula (Spain or Portugal). If you were a Creole, you descended from Europeans but you were born in the New World. If you were a Mestizo, you descended from one white parent and one parent with Indian heritage. If you were a Mulatto, you were a free person of color (having at least one parent of African descent). Indians were the people living in Latin America before the Spanish colonized there. Slaves were of African descent, some even born in Africa. And, as history has often showed, the people with power made up the smallest percentages of the population: the Peninsulares.

My group's timeline of the Mexican Revolution
When comparing the Brazil, the Gran Colombia, and the Mexico revolutions we discovered some similarities between the three outbreaks. All three revolts were around the early 1800s and they were all against European countries who colonized and controlled them. All of the people not of European decent were fighting against the Peninsulares (lower class against the upper class). The revolutions were also somewhat different in that Gran Columbia and Mexico took place in Spain and were both very violent revolts, unlike Brazil, which took place in Portugal, and provoked very little fighting. Both Brazil and Gran Columbia had a government made up of only Peninsulares and the mixed lower classes wanted to overthrow them. Mexico was run by Peninsulares as well as Creoles. Countries were choosing their leaders based on race (white people in power, people of mixed race were in lower classes) rather than choosing them in a way that considers the real aspects of a good leader. Our class has just written a DBQ about Toussaint Louverture, the leader of a widely known slave rebellion. He was African American and possessed amazing leadership qualities. If his race were to prevent him from spreading his influence on those that were affected by it in a positive way, that would change history for the worse. When you’re a kid, you must’ve been told, “It’s what’s on the inside that counts”. If someone’s outward appearance blinds us from the capable qualities they possess, then revolts will inevitably and rightfully occur.

I think it’s very rare that, in our society today, we’ll make it through a whole month without hearing a story about racial discrimination. It’s hard for people to not consider someone’s race when figuring out their first impression of them. I’m not saying it’s right for someone to judge another person based off their race, but it’s hard for most people to ignore it. Then, in addition to that, there’s the dispute if it’s right for us to ignore it. Last year, in history, we took a survey about the future of America and one question asked if America should be colorblind or a melting pot; one ignoring all race and one embracing the different cultures and heritages. Either one is in support of equal rights. No one’s race should determine what they’re capable of; let alone what they’re incapable of. 

Saturday, November 22, 2014

The Legacy of Louverture (DBQ)

Rulers should possess countless admirable qualities, such as honesty, eloquence, compassion, etc. A great ruler is typically only remembered for one specific quality, even if they possess all of the previously mentioned and more. Toussaint Louverture, the leader of the wildly remembered slave rebellion in Haiti, had many different aspects of his character and is remembered differently by historians today. Toussaint was born into slavery in the 1740s on the island of Saint Domingue which was first established as Hispaniola by Columbus and later renamed the independent country of Haiti. Under French control and producing 40% of the world's sugar as well as more than 50% of the world's coffee, Saint Domingue was one of the richest colonies in the world. In 1789, when the ideas of the French Revolution spread to the island, slaves, working on the plantations to produce the sugar and coffee, decided it was time to fight for their freedom. As a newly freed man, Toussaint Louverture played his part in helping the revolutionaries fight for their cause by commanding a rebel army of 4,000 troops in 1793. By 1794 he was appointed commander-in-chief of the army of Saint Domingue after France had abolished slavery and he had pledged his allegiance. Unfortunately, when Napoleon rose to power, there were rumors of reinstating slavery on the island. Toussaint then retracted his allegiance to France and led the islanders to put up an impressive fight against the 21,000 French troops invading the island in 1802. Toussaint was captured and brought to France where he died from pneumonia in a jail cell. He never knew Haiti defeated Napoleon and got their freedom in 1804. As such an influential leader, it's hard to pinpoint exactly what Toussaint’s legacy was. A legacy is what gets passed down from generation to generation in someone’s memory. Toussaint Louverture should be remembered as a liberator of slaves, a military commander, and the ruler of Saint Domingue.

Despite his admirable military tactics and his inspiring leadership skills, Toussaint should be remembered as a liberator of slaves because that was his main goal throughout the revolution. In 1974, “The revolutionary government in France under Robespierre abolishes slavery in France and all its colonies; Toussaint and his troops stop their revolt and now support the French.” (A). After fighting against the French for almost five years, Toussaint allies with his former enemy as soon as they give him what he wants: freedom for the people of Saint Domingue. And, when, “Napoleon sends 21,000 soldiers to Saint Domingue to reinstate slavery” (A), Toussaint switches back to fighting against France. The stability of his allegiances were questionable but his dedication to the cause definite. Toussaint was fighting to abolish slavery and whoever was against that was his opponent. When it was rumored that the French Directory wanted to reinstate slavery, Toussaint wrote a letter in which he threatened the French by saying, “We have known how to confront danger to our liberty, and we will know how to confront death to preserve it.” (B). He cannot and will not submit to the chains of slavery after he’s worked so hard to be free. Toussaint only plays the role of a military leader, threatening to use his troops against France, when it’s necessary to complete his task as a liberator of slaves.

Although not as important as freeing his fellow captives, Toussaint was a remarkable military commander. It is said that, “By his genius and surpassing activity, Toussaint levied fresh forces, raised the reputation of the army, and drove the English and Spanish from the island…” (F). Toussaint’s admirably strong grasp on the forces of Saint Domingue and the positive effect his leadership had on them was well known during this time. Not only was he marvelous in leading his troops to victory, but he also knew how to handle the soldiers when they got unruly. When a revolt broke out against his newly implemented labor policy, which stated free workers must return to work in the plantations, Toussaint showed how he reacts to soldiers who aren’t doing their jobs: “Toussaint himself was so enraged that when he passed through the rebel zone he ordered the mutineer regiments on parade and summoned certain men to step out of the ranks and blow their brains out…” (E). Sentencing the rebellious soldiers to death may be a bit harsh, but it kept Toussaint in control of the island and stabilized his position as the leader. His remarkable leadership abilities stretched farther than just the military.

Toussaint Louverture is also remembered as the capable ruler of Saint Domingue. He is declared their ruler in the constitution when it says, “The Constitution nominate citizen Toussaint-Louverture, Chief General of the army of Saint-Domingue and… he is entrusted the direction thereof for the remainder of his glorious life.” (C). The island of Saint Domingue had already seen Toussaint’s leadership qualities during the early revolts and he had shown them that they can instill their faith in him. Unfortunately, the citizens did not always realize he had their best interests at heart. In 1801, after Toussaint implemented new laws of labor, one of which stating, “As soon as a child can walk, he should be employed on the plantation according to his strength in some useful work…” (D), the citizens began to turn on him. Toussaint knew if their production rates for their crops went down after France had abolished slavery, slavery would be reestablished. He wanted what was best for the islanders and if hard decisions had to be made, he was willing to make them.

Throughout Toussaint Louverture’s life, his main goal was not to be the great ruler of Saint Domingue or a notable military leader, but only to be a liberator of slaves. He threatened the French Directory with his military forces, but only when it was necessary in order to avoid the reimplementation of slavery. He made harsh decisions as a military commander to ensure the newly free citizens of Saint Domingue would remain under control and not display any signs for possibly being better off in a society with slavery. As the ruler of Saint Domingue he implemented laws that would keep the island’s production rates high so France would have no reason to think slavery was required for the island to make the money they had previously been making with slavery. Although Toussaint Louverture took strong actions in the fields of military and ultimate leadership, his intentions were always focused on the liberation of slaves.

A: Created from various sources.
B: Toussaint Louverture, “Letter to the French Directory, November 1797.”
C: The Saint Domingue Constitution of 1801. Signed by Toussaint Louverture in July 1801.
D: Toussaint Louverture, “Proclamation, 25 November 1801.”
E: Madison Smartt Bell, Toussaint Louverture: A Biography, 2007.
F: William Wells Brown, “A Description of Toussaint Louverture,” from The Black Man, His Antecedents, His Genius, and His Achievements, 2nd edition, 1863. Engraving of Toussaint Louverture, 1802.

Sunday, November 9, 2014

Failure is a Matter of Opinion

Our failure scale
As students, we don’t exactly know how to measure failure. We have so much time left in our lives that any “failure” made now can be fixed by the time the books of our lives are sealed shut. Only when looked back on things can we decided whether or not they should be deemed a failure. In class, we inspected the way many historians have judged the revolts of the mid 1800s by posing this question: were the revolutions of 1830 and 1948 really failures as many historians have concluded? To start off the week, we created a scale that defined the outcomes of revolutions ranging from a complete failure to a complete success. SurveyMonkey to create a quiz about our revolution for our class to take. We then worked in groups of 4-5 to research specific revolts during this time. We read an online document about our assigned revolution, answered some guiding questions, and used

As you can see from our results on our
 SurveyMonkey questions, we recieved a
 variety of different answers.
I had the pleasure of working with the Decembrist group. The Decembrist Revolt  took place throughout December 1825 in Russia. People were unhappy with Tsar Alexander I’s ruling tactics and planned to overthrow him.
Some questions, such as this one, required
students to pay more attention to things other
than just the writing in the source. (The
answer to this question was in the title).
They wanted to replace him with his older brother Constantine, despite Constantine’s blatant statement that he did not want to be in power. After the Tsar’s unexpected death, Nicholas took to the throne. The rebels revolted in hopes of developing a weaker monarchy, abolishing slavery and abuse of power. Dmitry Zavalishin, a Decembrist, writes about the 1793 constitution granted to Poland and says, “Russians were offended at the granting of a constitution to defeated and conquered Poland before one was given to Russia, which vanquished it.” If Poland, who had been defeated by Russia, could handle the implementation of a constitution, then Russia, their superiors, should be able to too. Nicholas ended up firing on his own people to defeat the rebels. He shut down any contact outside of the country and took away religious freedom as well as all other rights. Nicholas explains his reaction to the revolt by saying, “The laws demand retribution and, in their cases, I will not use my power to grant mercy. I will be unbending; it is my duty to give this lesson to Russia and to Europe.” Nicholas was too stuck in his conservatism mindset to see past the threat of the revolution and look into its meaning. He didn’t even consider implementing changes to the way he ruled, he only thought to prevent any future revolutions.

Like the Decembrist Revolt, many other revolutions during this time were not successes. The French Revolution of 1848 lived a short success: the bourgeoisie prospering for a short time until Napoleon eventually brought down his empire and ended France’s leadership in Europe. The Frankfurt Assembly concluded with hundreds of people killed and thousands of Germans leaving their homeland. The Hungary revolt led to the imprisonment, execution, and exile of many. These revolts were all in favor of liberalism, the people wanted more rights and a weaker monarchy. Historians are right to consider these revolutions to be a failure, seeing as they led to the death of thousands of people. But despite that, they succeeded in spreading liberalist ideas throughout Europe. These revolutions helped created the world we live in today. The immediate outcome of these revolts wasn’t a success, and because of the massive number of deaths they caused I can’t imagine they’d ever be considered one, but because they succeeded in spreading a message, I think it’s fair to put them fairly close to neutral on the grand scale of failure.

Sunday, October 26, 2014

Power Is Spelled G.O.D.

              Year after year on the first day of school, I’ve received a handout explaining the stages of punishment in the classroom. You know what I’m talking about: it starts with a verbal warning and ends with you and your parents in the principal’s office. Teachers like us to know we can’t get away with acting out in their classes. But can you blame them? They can’t let their students walk all over them; they need to keep us in line. This past week in class, we discussed what people in power should do when their power is threatened. To start off, we went through a background reading that describes the representatives from each country that attended the Congress of Vienna. We then looked at a reading that focuses on the problems the Congress of Vienna was trying to solve and chose which solution we thought would be best. We worked in small groups and posted our reasons for choosing our desired solutions on our class padlet. After seeing how we, as a class, would solve the problems, we took notes on how these problems were actually solved. The way my classmates chose to handle the 19th century loss of power were not the ways those actually present in the 19th century chose to handle it.
1815: The Holy Alliance
http://www.voltairenet.org/article170096.html
              Napoleon, as you can read about in my past post, defeated most European countries, which meant most European countries belonged to France. Although Napoleon was a great fighter, he was also a ruthless one, which left the people of Europe with enough warfare to last them a life time. How would the Quintuple Alliance (Russia, Austria, Prussia, Britain, and France) prevent future revolutions and violence in Europe? They decided to establish a Holy Alliance. This stated that monarchs had the divine right to rule and that any revolution was treason against God. At this time, people were heavily concerned with their afterlife and the idea of doing something that would wind them up in Hell terrified them.

              In my opinion, this was a brilliant way to stifle rebellions. The leaders needed to force people into compliance without the violence used by Napoleon. By saying it as a sin to rebel, people kept themselves in line. God was most important in society and the representatives at the Congress of Vienna knew that the ever present eye of God would shield them from any outbreaks by the citizens. If there came a time when it was evident that those in power were unfit to rule, then those rulers should sacrifice their power for the good of the country. But, seeing as the Congress of Vienna was mostly successful in what they had set out to do, I don’t think these rulers would have to make any sacrifices like that. 

Thursday, October 23, 2014

Who's idea was it to have ideologies anyways?

In high school, the social classes are divided between what's 'cool' and 'not cool'. Politics are known to be divided between democrats and republicans. Things were not always split up in these ways. This past week, my class focused on the major political ideologies of the 19th century and how they influenced social and political action. We were divided into six groups and the three ideologies (liberalism, conservatism and nationalism) were assigned amongst the groups. As it worked out, each ideology would be presented by two different groups. This lead to a "show down" in which we would vote on the group that best presented the each ideology. Three groups, including mine, used an app called chatterpix, which allows you to make a picture talk. One group made a common craft video, one group made a movie in educreations and another group performed a skit. The class then worked together to come up with a definition for each of the ideologies. Once the hard work was done we voted on who's presentation was best. My group, being the winners, got two delectable  Hershey kisses.

Our chatterpix about liberalism
My group was assigned liberalism. We used chatterpix to make a photo of Adam Smith describe what liberalism was in the form of a haiku. If you remember from my past post, Adam Smith created the theory of the Invisible Hand. He wanted everyone to contribute to the economy. By "everyone", I don't mean everyone in society. I mean everyone accepted by society, which is really only the middle class and higher. Our haiku didn't really go into an indepth explanation of liberalism, as it is very hard to give specifics when you're given a limited number of syllables. We gave the main points of liberalism such as the focus on meritocracy and the opposition to traditions. Liberalists promoted constitutional rights as opposed to a monarchy. They tried to end the traditional rights belonging to the aristocracy as well as the church. Taking power away from the church was a big change at this time in history because it had previously had an enormous effect in the everyday life of society.

Conservatism is the opposite of liberalism. One group used chatterpix to show Edmund Burke describing the main ideas from his book about conservatism. The other group used educreations to show a family enforcing the traditions of the monarchy in the household. Our class defined conservatism as a system of government that wanted to protect the monarchy and keep the old traditions. These traditions include the rights of the aristocracy and monarchy, as well as the role of the church. Conservatives view revolution as troublesome and, for lack of a better word, dumb. Change is not a priority. The last ideology is nationalism. The first group made a chatterpix displaying a group of m&ms arguing over which color m&m is best. The candies eventually unite to defeat a skittle because, despite their differences, they're all chocolate and the skittle is most definitely not. The other group performed a skit which included three students fighting over who was better, only to eventually unite, because of their shared cultural background, to defeat a foreign invader. Nationalism is the belief that people should unite through common traits in order to prevent foreign rulers from taking over. The common traits are usually along the lines of similar cultural practices, religion, languages, beliefs and traditions. These contradicting ideas still play a part in our society today.

Tuesday, October 14, 2014

Napoleon (Bonaparte) Was Dynamite For France

Military portrait of Napoleon Bonaparte.
Napoleon.
When I was younger I would always mix up Napoleon Dynamite and Napoleon Bonaparte. At the time I had no idea I was comparing a fictional character to a great historical leader. In class we watched a five minute video that gave an overview of Napoleon Bonaparte’s life and accomplishments. Napoleon grew up in France, attending military schools from the age of nine. He worked himself up the ranks of the French military and went on to lead many successful invasions, conquering most of Europe. Napoleon’s ways of leadership were hated as well as praised by the people of France. Nevertheless, Napoleon left his footprint most aspects of our daily lives.
In class, we looked at a list of accomplishments Napoleon worked on during his leadership and decided which parts of his rule effected France and which effected the world. we concluded that Napoleon greatly helped the economy of France. He encouraged new industry, built roads and canals for trading, and established the Bank of France. Napoleon also greatly changed the political and social systems of Europe by establishing a meritocracy, which means people’s chances of success was determined based on their skills, rather than their social class. In an article called “The Lost Voices", a quote from Napoleon and His Marshalls, a book written in 1847 by Joel Tyler Headley, says the meritocracy was a system that is responsible for, “opening the field to talent and genius, however low their birth”.  

The meritocracy was more beneficial for some than for others. The rich, who were previously successful because of their given birth right, were not pleased with the social and political changes. In class, we read reviews from two citizens, Madame de Staël and Marshal Michel Ney, about their feelings toward Napoleon. Madame de Staël, a wealthy woman in France, opposed the changes made during Napoleon's leadership. She says, “He would like to persuade men by force and by cunning, and he considers all else to be stupid and folly.” She thought lowly of him as a ruler because the changes he made during his rule were unbeneficial for her. Marshal Michel Ney, one of Napoleon’s soldiers, greatly admired him. He refers to Napoleon as, “our sovereign” and, “our angst emperor”. Because the changes Napoleon made during his rule were received well among the middle and lower classes, which made up the majority of the population, the people who worked with him, such as the soldiers, benefited from his success. But those who thought lowly of Napoleon, such as Madame de Staël, were no match for his empire, seeing as she was eventually exiled from France for speaking against the powerful ruler. 

Thursday, October 9, 2014

Team Marx or Team Smith

Walking into a class and seeing two humongous bags of Hershey’s Kisses always brightens up a morning. In class on Monday, we recreated Charles Marx’s theory of communism with pieces of chocolate. Everyone in the class started with two Hershey’s Kisses, except for the two lucky students who got eight. My classmates were very upset, not at our teacher for the unfair distribution, but rather at the students who got lucky during the distribution, saying things like, “Let’s gang up on Brian”. Poor Brian. We then went around the room playing rock, paper, scissors, shoot; the winners got a piece of the loser’s chocolate. When a student lost all of their candy they had to sit down. Few kids who started with two kisses ended up with any chocolate but those who got eight lasted until the end. Comments were made along the lines of “rich people stink” and “I hate my life”. The teacher then collected all of the candy and redistributed it so everyone got two and only two. When given the option to play rock, paper, scissors again, the class voted against it in fear of losing their chocolate again.
Karl Marx.
http://spartacus-educational.com/TUmarx.htm
Marx's theory of communism starts with capitalism. This includes private ownership of industry and freedom of competition. Marx says capitalism results in unequal economic classes, lower classes struggling and workers revolting. In order to make things more fair, Marx said people would create a government system of socialism. This government system would own industry and hopefully bring economic equality in a classless society. Marx said that people would revolt against divisions between rich and poor and by any means necessary, even violence, the people would create communism. In this system, no government is needed and the goal of a classless society is achieved. This gives the poor an equal chance at success as the rich because everyone starts on a level playing field thanks to the redistribution of goods. Another theory is Adam Smith’s Invisible Hand. Companies will treat their workers better because the employees are also the customers.
Adam Smith.
http://livingeconomiesforum.org/Adam-Smith
Smith said that if government left industry alone, people will buy, sell, and run businesses on their own. Businesses that operate honestly and don’t cheat their customers will succeed and those that do not will fail. This benefits the poor because, eventually, high quality goods will be available at lower prices. Because employees work near the shops they live and shop at the stores closest to them, stores need to pay their workers enough so they can afford their products.
An alternate system would be a compromise between both Marx’s theory and Smith’s theory. These two systems don't include a government. Maybe that's what they're missing. If we could incorporate the level playing field that Marx wanted everyone to start with and smith's idea of a hands off economy, we might get respectable results. The government should have the ability to create and sponsor stores. When unemployment rates are up and poverty seems to have reached a high, the government should open some stores, such as a grocery store or a laundry mat. The government can buy the supplies and sell them at a reasonable price. Plus these government stores can employ citizens without jobs. These stores will function as the goal of the invisible hand: high quality goods at low prices. And once the economy is stable and more stores can match the rates of the government stores, those stores can sell their businesses and the hands off mentality can be resumed.